At a crucial National Security Council meeting in July 1965, during which President Lyndon Johnson and his advisers were deliberating whether the United States should intervene militarily in South Vietnam with 100,000 troops, US Ambassador to South Vietnam Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr delivered the coup de grâce to those vacillating about the intervention: ‘I feel there is a greater threat to start World War III if we don’t go in [to save South Vietnam]. Can’t we see the similarity to our own indolence at Munich?’1 Thirty years later, US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright also felt it necessary to remind her interlocutors, when dealing with ethnic cleansing in the Balkans, that her ‘mindset is Munich’,2 not Vietnam. Her pro-military intervention mindset pitted her against the then chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Colin Powell, whom she needled with her famous comment ‘What’s the point of having this superb military that you’re always talking about if we can’t use it?’3 Powell was so dismayed by Albright’s willingness to send US troops in harm’s way that ‘I thought I would have an aneurysm’.4
The point of departure of this article is that what Lodge and Albright were doing is unexceptional: when confronted with new challenges, they looked to the past for guidance. But as the Vietnam debacle and Powell’s reaction to Albright suggest, it is also true that looking to the past to assess the present (and future) is strewn with risks. The invocation of the Hippocratic ‘do no harm’ oath by the editors of this special issue undoubtedly applies to decision-makers predisposed to ‘learning’ and applying the lessons of history in dealing with foreign policy challenges. Scholars who have examined how policy-makers use historical analogies in international affairs agree that in most of those cases, their analogies—insofar as they shaped the decision—have led to suboptimal outcomes, or what the editors call ‘failures’.
This article attempts to do two things: first, to glean from existing studies of ‘failures’ in using the lessons of history in international affairs a set of ‘how not tos’ that can help steer the process of using history away from the wrong paths towards something better; and second, to examine the extent to which these ‘how not to’ proscriptions have informed the way policy-makers and analysts are using history in a contemporary case. I will proceed as follows. In the first part of the article, I draw on existing analyses of how policy-makers have used the ‘lessons of the past’ in their foreign policy decision-making to suggest a few ‘how not to’ proscriptions on using history.5 My survey of the existing literature on the pitfalls of analogical reasoning in international affairs leads us to four related ‘how not to’ strictures: (1) do not settle or fixate on the first or most evocative analogy that comes to mind; (2) do not dismiss differences between your favoured analogy and the case in question; (3) do not neglect alternative analogies; and (4) do not shirk from ‘testing’ the observable implications of your preferred analogy. Decision-makers who show awareness of these ‘how not tos’ in using the lessons of the past, I argue, are less likely to commit the errors that plague the unaware.
The second part of the article explores the extent to which these four ‘how not tos’ manifest themselves in a contemporary case of ‘learning from the past’. The case I have chosen is how the United States and its strategic partners are using historical analogies to interpret the nature and trajectory of US–China relations today. Research indicates that four historical analogies figure prominently in the contemporary worldwide debate about the nature and challenge posed by China’s rise: Athens–Sparta (or ‘the Thucydides Trap’), the First World War, the Second World War or Munich, and the Cold War. Of these four, the Cold War analogy is emerging as the key interpretative schema and it will be the focus of the analysis here. I shall pay special attention to how policy-makers (former and current), rather than scholars, use the analogy, because it is the use of analogies by those with policy influence, such as former US Secretaries of State Henry Kissinger and Mike Pompeo, that shapes thinking and debate in the policy sphere.
The use of the Cold War analogy is not limited to the US policy community. China’s leaders, for example, often accuse the United States of adopting a ‘Cold War mentality’ in its diplomatic approach to Asia in general, and China in particular, but they seldom spell out what that mentality involves other than to imply a hegemonic US bent on retarding China’s rise.6 Other policy-makers in Asia, Europe and Africa—as I will show below—are also latching on to the Cold War parallel to make sense of US–China relations and the implications for their respective countries and regions.7 My focus, however, will be on the analogy’s usage by the United States and its strategic partners (Australia in particular). This focus is justified by the fact that the most systematic and detailed articulations of the analogy are to be found in debates within the US. This should not come as a surprise, given that the United States (and its strategic partners in Asia) are the ones most in need of getting the ‘diagnosis’ about the nature and stakes of the China challenge right if they are to construct appropriate strategies to meet the challenge.
My analysis of how the Cold War analogy is being deployed suggests that its users have avoided the worst pitfalls of analogical reasoning in foreign affairs. The most prominent users of these historical analogies show awareness of the first three of the above proscriptions; all, however, shy away from the fourth—the need to test the prognostications of their favoured analogy. Although this is far from perfect, the signs point to the Cold War analogy being used in ways that avoid the general pattern of superficial and poor use documented in existing analyses of analogical reasoning in foreign affairs.
Authored by Yuen Foong Khong | International Affairs, Volume 98, Issue 5, September 2022 | Download the complete report from here.
Related MCQs
- Ukraine Eastern region Donetsk and Luhansk collectively known as? (CSS 2023 Current Affairs Paper)
- Crimea
- Donbas
- Galicia
- East Ukraine
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- What is the literal meaning of the word Tehzib? (CSS 2019 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Purification
- Trimming
- Scarification
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The currency in Norway is? (CSS 2022 Current Affairs Paper)
- Norwegian Krone
- Norwegian Dollar
- Norwegian Pound
- None of the above
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The word \"Muhammad\" (صلَّی اللہ تعالٰی علیہ واٰلہٖ وسلَّم) as a name has been mentioned in the Qur\'an only? (CSS 2009 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Only once
- Two times
- Three times
- Four times
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- When was gas(natural)discovered at sui Baluchistan? (CSS 2010 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- 1950
- 1952
- 1954
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Collection of water droplets which are suspended in air called? (CSS 2018 General Science & Ability Paper)
- Wind
- Cloud
- Gases
- Sleet
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- 9th Zil-Hajja is also called? (CSS 2010 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Yaum-e-Arfat
- Waquf-e-Arafat
- Yaum-e-Mina
- Waqufe-e-Mina
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- \'In the Line of Fire\' is a book, written by? (PPSC Tehsildar General Knowledge Test, December 15, 2024)
- Ayesha Jalal
- Mohsin Hamid
- Pervez Musharraf
- Mohammed Hanif
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Proteins are made up of? (CSS 2012 General Science & Ability Paper)
- Polynucleotide
- Polypeptide
- Oxyacetylene
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The Pakistani Republican party was formed in October 1955. The President of the party was? (CSS 2018 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- Nawab Muzaffar Ali Khan Qizilbash
- Mirza Mumtaz Hassan Qizilbash
- Dr Khan Sahib
- Nawab Akbar Khan Bugti
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Operation Zarb-e-Azab was launched on? (CSS 2019 Current Affairs Paper)
- 24 April 2014
- 29 April 2014
- 15 June 2014
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The scientific management approach means? (CSS 2023 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- Use of scientific methods for optimizing work processes to increase productivity
- Use of scientific methods for employee Assistance
- Both
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Splitting of the moon occurred in? (CSS 2010 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Arafat
- Mina
- Muzdalifa
- Haram e Pak
Submitted by: None of these
- A Verse Of Holy Quran Indicates The Name of? (CSS 2018 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Hazrat Muaaz(رضی اللّٰہ عنہ)
- Hazrat Bilal(رضی اللّٰہ عنہ)
- Hazrat Saad(رضی اللّٰہ عنہ)
- Hazrat Zaid(رضی اللّٰہ عنہ)
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The incident of splitting of moon Occurred at which place? (CSS 2014 Islamic Studies Paper)
- Makkah
- Madina
- Mina
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Which provincial Chief Minister was dismissed on the issue of One Unit? (CSS 2009 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- Chief Minister NWFP
- Chief Minister Sindh
- Chief Minister Punjab
- Chief Minister Baluchistan
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Since January 2019 how many times legislative elections have been held in Israel? (CSS 2021 Current Affairs Paper)
- One
- Two
- Three
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- An eclipse of the Sun occurs when? (CSS 2011 General Science & Ability Paper)
- The Moon is between the Sun and the Earth
- The Sun is between the Earth and the Moon
- The Earth is between the Sun and the Moon
- The Earth casts its shadow on the Moon
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The magnet always points in the same direction, if allowed to move freely i.e. towards North and South poles, because of? (CSS 2011 General Science & Ability Paper)
- Gravitational field
- Earth is a huge magnet
- A lot of metal deposits on North and South Poles
- Due to attraction of North Pole and repulsion of Western Pole
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Vitamins A, D, E and K are called? (CSS 2014 General Science & Ability Paper)
- Water soluble vitamins
- Primary vitamins
- Basic vitamins
- Fat soluble vitamins
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- No person shall be appointed as a judge of the Supreme Court of Pakistan unless he has been a judge of a High Court for a period of? (CSS 2024 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- Five years
- Seven years
- Nine years
- Fifteen year
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- In which year Pakistan become ‘Republic’? (CSS 2011 Pakistan Affairs Paper)
- 1947
- 1956
- 1962
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Ozone layer absorb most of the? (CSS 2015 Current Affairs Paper)
- Ultraviolet radiations
- Sun’s ultraviolet (UV) radiation
- Both a & b
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- The border dispute between India and Nepal is? (CSS 2023 Current Affairs Paper)
- Kalapani
- Nalapani
- Lipulekh
- None of these options
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team
- Which of the following is P-type semiconductor? (CSS 2020 General Science & Ability Paper)
- Germanium
- Gallium
- Silicon
- None of these
Submitted by: CSS Exam Desk Team